Skip to content
Dale Ledger · Scarsdale

Dale Ledger · Scarsdale edition · Infarill LLC

Largest assessment increases in Scarsdale, 2025 to 2026

Between the 2025 and 2026 rolls, 177 Scarsdale properties went up in assessed value, 295 went down, and 4,749 stayed about the same. This page lists the 50 biggest increases by percentage.

Increases this large usually come from a finished renovation or addition, a teardown replaced by new construction, a subdivision, or a correction to a parcel the assessor had valued too low. A big increase alone does not mean the assessment is wrong.

If your assessment rose sharply and similar homes on your street barely changed, ask the assessor why. The median by street table shows how much a typical home on each street changed. Grievance season in Westchester covers the deadlines and the process if you decide to challenge your assessment.

Parcels with a full market value under $200,000 on the prior roll are left out. At that size, a large percentage change is usually a reclassification or a data correction.

#AddressChangeFull market valueAssessedEst. annual taxSchool zone
187 Carthage Rd+875.0%$2,914,362$1,950,000$54,059Heathcote
2271 Madison Rd+220.0%$2,989,089$2,000,000$55,446Edgewood
316 Hamilton Rd+220.0%$2,989,089$2,000,000$55,446Edgewood
436 Secor Rd+207.7%$4,483,634$3,000,000$83,168Heathcote
58 Dell Rd+194.4%$3,960,544$2,650,000$73,465Quaker Ridge
6174 Boulevard+180.0%$2,615,453$1,750,000$48,514Fox Meadow
7190 Madison Rd+176.2%$1,868,181$1,250,000$34,653Edgewood
8189 Heathcote Rd+166.7%$8,967,269$6,000,000$166,337Heathcote
965 Fox Meadow Rd+162.8%$3,997,907$2,675,000$74,159Fox Meadow
1032 Sycamore Rd+155.9%$4,035,271$2,700,000$74,851Quaker Ridge
118 Crest La+154.5%$3,138,544$2,100,000$58,217Quaker Ridge
12126 Birchall Dr+146.4%$6,351,815$4,250,000$117,821Heathcote
1337 Penn Blv+141.1%$6,575,997$4,400,000$121,980Quaker Ridge
1472 Chase Rd+133.9%$5,156,179$3,450,000$95,643Fox Meadow
1554 Harvest Dr+129.8%$4,035,271$2,700,000$74,851Quaker Ridge
1613 Overlook Rd+118.1%$5,604,543$3,750,000$103,960Fox Meadow
17177 White Rd+114.2%$2,167,090$1,450,000$40,198Edgewood
181 Coralyn Rd+109.8%$1,685,099$1,127,500$31,257Quaker Ridge
1919 Black Hawk Rd+107.9%$3,213,271$2,150,000$59,604Quaker Ridge
2066 Sheldrake Rd+100.0%$7,472,724$5,000,000$138,613Heathcote
212 Wynmor Rd+100.0%$2,391,271$1,600,000$44,357Heathcote
22114 Lee Rd+83.3%$2,054,999$1,375,000$38,118Fox Meadow
23112 Lee Rd+83.3%$2,054,999$1,375,000$38,118Fox Meadow
2423 Autenrieth Rd+75.0%$4,184,725$2,800,000$77,624Fox Meadow
2544 Carthage Rd+73.0%$2,241,817$1,500,000$41,583Heathcote
2612 Burgess Rd+64.9%$8,070,542$5,400,000$149,703Heathcote
2718 Lincoln Rd+63.6%$5,380,361$3,600,000$99,801Heathcote
2823 Crossway+60.0%$2,391,271$1,600,000$44,357Heathcote
297 Normandy La+58.8%$4,035,271$2,700,000$74,851Quaker Ridge
305 Hillview Dr+58.5%$3,138,544$2,100,000$58,217Quaker Ridge
3120 Cambridge Rd+58.1%$5,081,452$3,400,000$94,258Greenacres
3226 Overhill Rd+56.8%$5,156,179$3,450,000$95,643Fox Meadow
332 Kathy La+48.4%$1,718,726$1,150,000$31,881Fox Meadow
3451 Ogden Rd+47.7%$3,287,998$2,200,000$60,990Fox Meadow
3514 Stonehouse Rd+47.2%$3,960,544$2,650,000$73,465Fox Meadow
3620 Heathcote Rd+46.7%$13,151,995$8,800,000$243,959Heathcote
377 Sycamore Rd+46.0%$2,204,453$1,475,000$40,891Quaker Ridge
3827 Whig Rd+45.0%$3,250,635$2,175,000$60,297Fox Meadow
394 Sherbrooke Rd+44.3%$8,780,451$5,875,000$162,871Heathcote
4082 Sprague Rd+44.0%$1,345,090$900,000$24,950Edgewood
4179 Penn Rd+41.8%$3,138,544$2,100,000$58,217Quaker Ridge
42239 Nelson Rd+41.5%$1,942,908$1,300,000$36,040Edgewood
4319 Black Birch La+41.0%$2,054,999$1,375,000$38,118Quaker Ridge
445 Barker La+40.8%$6,314,452$4,225,000$117,129Quaker Ridge
451 Tory La+38.8%$2,876,998$1,925,000$53,367Fox Meadow
463 Coralyn Rd+37.7%$1,105,963$740,000$20,516Quaker Ridge
4774 Huntington Ave+37.1%$2,129,726$1,425,000$39,505Greenacres
4821 Barry Rd+36.8%$1,942,908$1,300,000$36,040Edgewood
4910 Cornell St+34.3%$3,213,271$2,066,362$57,285Quaker Ridge
5042 Mamaroneck Rd+33.3%$9,565,087$6,400,000$177,424Heathcote

Source: Scarsdale 2026 assessment roll (SWIS 555000), compiled by Infarill LLC. Estimated taxes use county, school, and village mill rates for fiscal year 2026 county / 2026-27 village / 2026-27 school and leave out special district charges. Dale Ledger is unofficial and is not affiliated with any municipality or school district. Check figures with the PROS.

Search the full Scarsdale roll · Browse Scarsdale by street · How Westchester property tax works

FAQ

Why did my Scarsdale assessment go up in 2026?

Common causes are a finished renovation or addition, new construction, a subdivision, or a correction to an assessment that was too low. The assessor's office can tell you which one applies to your parcel.

Can I challenge an assessment increase?

Yes. New York has a formal grievance process with set yearly deadlines. An increase on its own is not grounds for a grievance. The question is whether your assessment is too high compared with similar properties.

Open Scarsdale search

Unofficial. Confirm figures on PROS (the county property records system) and the Village assessment rolls before you act on them.