Skip to content
Dale Ledger · Rye

Dale Ledger · City of Rye edition · Infarill LLC

Rye homes whose assessments rose more than their street's

Comparing one home's assessment with the town average does not say much, because streets differ in value for reasons that have nothing to do with how the assessor treated your parcel. Compare your home with the other homes on your street.

Homes on the same street are usually similar in age, lot size, and market, so their assessments usually move together. When parcels a few doors down barely changed and one jumped, it is fair to ask the assessor why.

The table shows the 50 Rye parcels that rose the most compared with their street, out of 51 that qualify. Gaps are measured against 226 streets with at least 5 comparable parcels each. A parcel qualifies if it rose at least 10 percentage points more than its street's median, but less than 100.

Another 16 Rye parcels rose more than 100 points above their street. A change that large usually means the house was rebuilt, so those parcels are left off this page. They are on the biggest increases page.

A gap does not mean the assessment is wrong. A finished renovation, an addition, new construction, or a correction to a low assessment can each make one parcel rise faster than the rest of its street. This page uses only the published rolls, so it cannot see what is on the lot. If one of those happened at your house, that probably explains the gap.

If none of them did, ask the assessor what changed. Grievance season in Westchester lists the deadlines. If you miss one, you wait a year. Dale Ledger cannot file a grievance for you. Start with the City of Rye assessment rolls.

#Addressvs streetFull market valueAssessedEst. annual tax
1447 Midland Ave+80.6 pts$1,599,576$18,875$23,305
236 Tyler Cir+69.1 pts$1,612,288$19,025$23,490
37 Red Oak Dr+67.2 pts$3,542,373$41,800$51,611
4845 Forest Ave+64.5 pts$10,000,000$118,000$145,695
5112 Dearborn Ave+57.0 pts$1,949,153$23,000$28,398
6340 Midland Ave+52.1 pts$1,398,305$16,500$20,373
771 Oakland Beach Ave+50.4 pts$2,230,932$26,325$32,503
850 Brown Ave+48.1 pts$2,309,322$27,250$33,646
976 Glen Oaks Dr+47.8 pts$1,500,000$17,700$21,854
10251 Forest Ave+46.7 pts$2,701,271$31,875$39,356
1159 Franklin Ave+46.7 pts$1,889,831$22,300$27,535
1222 Chamberlain St+45.7 pts$2,500,000$29,500$36,424
1310 Ridgeland Ter+42.2 pts$813,559$9,600$11,853
147 Elmwood Ave+39.9 pts$1,404,661$16,575$20,465
1547 Adelaide St+37.6 pts$1,463,983$17,275$21,329
1612 Rickbern St+36.5 pts$1,847,458$21,800$26,916
1742 Davis Ave+36.0 pts$1,889,831$22,300$27,535
18454 Milton Rd+35.6 pts$1,330,508$15,700$19,385
19466 Milton Rd+35.3 pts$1,599,576$18,875$23,305
2030 Kirby Ln+35.2 pts$5,762,712$68,000$83,961
2135 Colby Ave+34.2 pts$1,961,864$23,150$28,583
2229 Grapal St+31.0 pts$2,114,407$24,950$30,806
2334 La Salle Ave+28.6 pts$2,364,407$27,900$34,448
2416 Henry St+25.9 pts$1,296,610$15,300$18,891
2527 N Kirby Ln+25.9 pts$4,000,000$47,200$58,279
2620 Greenleaf St+25.3 pts$4,199,153$49,550$61,180
2774 Island Dr+24.6 pts$8,500,000$100,300$123,841
2835 Island Dr+23.6 pts$5,550,847$65,500$80,874
292 Adelaide St+22.7 pts$1,627,119$19,200$23,707
30360 Grace Church St+20.8 pts$4,351,695$51,350$63,402
3124 Brown Ave+20.0 pts$2,847,458$33,600$41,486
3271 Island Dr+19.7 pts$5,771,186$68,100$84,083
331 Orchard Ln+19.3 pts$1,754,237$20,700$25,558
3443 Horton St+17.0 pts$2,042,373$24,100$29,756
35780 Forest Ave+16.4 pts$2,135,593$25,200$31,115
3633 Oakwood Ave+16.3 pts$1,525,424$18,000$22,224
3738 La Salle Ave+15.6 pts$3,703,390$43,700$53,957
387 Hillcrest Ln+14.2 pts$2,184,322$25,775$31,824
3960 North St+14.0 pts$1,656,780$19,550$24,138
401 Robert Crisfield Pl+13.7 pts$2,900,424$34,225$42,258
4153 Dearborn Ave+13.4 pts$1,682,203$19,850$24,509
4248 Rye Rd+12.3 pts$3,559,322$42,000$51,858
4316 Pine Island Rd+11.9 pts$7,983,051$94,200$116,310
4440 Roosevelt Ave+11.7 pts$1,216,102$14,350$17,718
4515 Harbor Ln+11.6 pts$1,930,085$22,775$28,120
4617 Manursing Way+11.1 pts$5,000,000$59,000$72,848
4715 Greenhaven Rd+11.1 pts$1,506,356$17,775$21,948
48145 Milton Rd+10.8 pts$7,900,424$93,225$115,105
4945 Meadow Pl+10.5 pts$1,834,746$21,650$26,731
5041 Walker Ave+10.1 pts$1,940,678$22,900$28,275

Get a reminder before the grievance deadline

Westchester grievance deadlines come once a year, and if you miss the date you wait a year. Leave your email and we will send you the Rye date once, before it arrives, and a note when the next roll is published.

This is optional. Leave it unticked and your email address goes to no one. We work with one grievance company, which we choose ourselves. We do not hand your details to a list of firms, and you will not hear from several companies because of us. We have not chosen one yet. Until a company is named on our Privacy page, nothing is shared with anyone. If you tick the box, we send that company your email address, your town and the page you were on, so it can contact you about your assessment. We may be paid for the introduction. Filing a grievance with your town is free, and you can do it yourself. How introductions work.

We use your email address to send what you asked for and an occasional Dale Ledger update. Every message has an unsubscribe link. We share it only if you tick the grievance box above.

Source: Rye 2026 assessment roll (SWIS 551400), compiled by Infarill LLC. Estimated taxes use county, school, and village mill rates for fiscal year 2026 city & county / 2026-27 school and leave out special district charges. Dale Ledger is unofficial and is not affiliated with any municipality or school district. Check figures with the City of Rye assessment rolls.

Search the full Rye roll · Browse Rye by street · How Westchester property tax works

FAQ

How do I know if I am over-assessed in Rye?

Compare how much your assessment changed with the median change on your own street. If yours rose much more and you have not renovated, built, or subdivided, ask the assessor about the gap.

Does a large gap mean my assessment is wrong?

No. A gap alone does not show an error. Renovations, additions, new construction, and corrections to a low assessment can all make a parcel rise faster than its street.

Can Dale Ledger file a grievance for me?

No. Dale Ledger is an unofficial site. It does not give tax advice or represent anyone. Only you or someone you authorize can file a grievance, and only the assessor and the Board of Assessment Review can change an assessment.

Open Rye search

Unofficial. Confirm figures on the City of Rye PROS (the county property records system) before you act on them. School district: Rye City School District.