Skip to content
Dale Ledger · Rye

Dale Ledger · City of Rye edition · Infarill LLC

The 50 most expensive homes in Rye

These are the 50 highest full market values on the Rye 2026 assessment roll. Full market value is the assessor's estimate of what a property would sell for. It is not a listing price or the price the home last sold for. The median across all 4,085 residential parcels in Rye is $2,000,000, so every home on this page is well above the typical one.

A high value does not always mean a high tax bill. Exemptions, STAR, and the split between county, school, and village taxes all change the final number, so the estimated tax column is not in the same order as value. Large parcels and estates are often valued as much for the land as for the house.

#AddressFull market valueAssessedEst. annual tax
1210 Boston Post Rd$51,911,017$612,550$756,320
220 Parsonage Point$25,000,000$295,000$364,238
312 Parsonage Point Pl$20,402,542$240,750$297,256
410 Parsonage Point Pl$20,169,492$238,000$293,860
544 Island Dr$19,067,797$225,000$277,809
614 Parsonage Point Pl$18,686,441$220,500$272,253
78 Parsonage Point Pl$17,796,610$210,000$259,288
88 S Manursing Island Rd$17,631,356$208,050$256,881
9890 Forest Ave$17,228,814$203,300$251,016
105 Guion Rd$16,779,661$198,000$244,472
11408 Grace Church St$15,466,102$182,500$225,335
129 Pine Island Rd$15,148,305$178,750$220,703
1320 Island Dr$14,745,763$174,000$214,840
1416 Parsonage Point Pl$14,487,288$170,950$211,073
1558 Island Dr$14,211,864$167,700$207,061
161 Fords Ln$14,050,847$165,800$204,715
176 Martin Butler Ct$13,898,305$164,000$202,492
181001 Forest Ave$13,605,932$160,550$198,232
1918 Parsonage Point Pl$13,072,034$154,250$190,453
20315 Brevoort Ln$13,050,847$154,000$190,145
215 Parsonage Point Pl$12,569,915$148,325$183,138
2214 Dogwood Ln$11,838,983$139,700$172,489
2357 Brevoort Ln$11,771,186$138,900$171,501
243 Martin Butler Ct$11,525,424$136,000$167,920
258 Pine Island Rd$11,525,424$136,000$167,920
2636 Island Dr$11,360,169$134,050$165,512
27140 Kirby Ln$11,347,458$133,900$165,327
2893 Rye Rd$11,186,441$132,000$162,981
29131 Kirby Ln$11,000,000$129,800$160,264
30330 Stuyvesant Ave$10,913,136$128,775$158,999
31290 Stuyvesant Ave$10,906,780$128,700$158,907
325 Martin Butler Ct$10,900,424$128,625$158,814
3310 Philips Ln$10,847,458$128,000$158,043
3475 Stuyvesant Ave$10,822,034$127,700$157,672
353 Lane Way Off Barlow Ln$10,750,000$126,850$156,623
366 Shore Rd$10,622,881$125,350$154,770
3711 Kirby Ln$10,542,373$124,400$153,597
38175 Stuyvesant Ave$10,338,983$122,000$150,635
39777 Forest Ave$10,250,000$120,950$149,337
4014 Island Dr$10,237,288$120,800$149,153
41859 Forest Ave$10,179,661$120,120$148,313
4240 Island Dr$10,177,966$120,100$148,289
437 S Manursing Island Rd$10,050,847$118,600$146,436
44845 Forest Ave$10,000,000$118,000$145,695
4595 Rye Rd$9,974,576$117,700$145,325
4680 Stuyvesant Ave$9,936,441$117,250$144,769
47999 Forest Ave$9,915,254$117,000$144,461
48168 Kirby Ln$9,811,017$115,770$142,942
49310 Stuyvesant Ave$9,694,915$114,400$141,250
5030 Island Dr$9,610,169$113,400$140,015

Source: Rye 2026 assessment roll (SWIS 551400), compiled by Infarill LLC. Estimated taxes use county, school, and village mill rates for fiscal year 2026 city & county / 2026-27 school and leave out special district charges. Dale Ledger is unofficial and is not affiliated with any municipality or school district. Check figures with the City of Rye assessment rolls.

Search the full Rye roll · Browse Rye by street · How Westchester property tax works

FAQ

What is the most expensive home in Rye, NY?

On the 2026 roll the highest full market value is $51,911,017 at 210 Boston Post Rd. This is the assessor's estimate of value. It is not a sale price.

Is this the same as the most expensive home sold in Rye?

No. These are the assessor's values, not sale prices. A home can be assessed above or below what it would sell for today.

Open Rye search

Unofficial. Confirm figures on the City of Rye PROS (the county property records system) before you act on them. School district: Rye City School District.