Geoghegan James & Jessica — 5 Onondaga St
5 Onondaga St is on the City of Rye 2026 assessment roll (parcel 139-19-1-43). Unofficial almanac — confirm on the published city roll.
- Full market$2,381,356
- Assessed$28,100
- Land$7,300
- Est. annual tax$33,903
Owner on roll: Geoghegan James & Jessica. Type: Single-family. School district: Rye City. Assessed change: +4.5% vs 2025.
How this compares to its street
This parcel's assessed value rose 4.5% between the last two rolls. Across the 9 comparable parcels on Onondaga St, the median did not change.
That is within 5 points of the street's median. Assessments on a block usually move together.
Screening comparison only, computed from published rolls. It does not account for what is physically on the lot. Confirm everything with the assessor before acting.
What the public record says about this property
This lot is inside the AE flood zone
The whole lot falls within the mapped Special Flood Hazard Area. FEMA describes AE as: 1% annual chance flood, base flood elevation published. A federally backed mortgage on a property in this zone requires flood insurance.
Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer
Compiled from published federal, state and municipal records on 2026-09-16. Each finding names its source and links to the agency that holds the underlying file. FEMA flood zones are regulatory map boundaries, not forecasts — flooding occurs outside them. A DEC spill record is a report filed at an address, not a determination about the building; a closed case means the agency closed its file. This section is not a risk score, an all-clear, or insurance, legal, appraisal, or real-estate advice. Confirm anything material with FEMA, DEC, your insurer, counsel, and the municipality before you act. See also Terms of Use.
Onondaga St street hub · Open in search · Markdown (agents) · Official rolls
Nearby on this street
- 2 Onondaga St
- 13 Onondaga St
- 19 Onondaga St
- 20 Onondaga St
- 25 Onondaga St
- 26 Onondaga St
- 35 Onondaga St
- 36 Onondaga St
FAQ
What is the assessed value of 5 Onondaga St?
On the 2026 City of Rye roll, parcel 139-19-1-43 is assessed at $28,100 with full market value $2,381,356.
What is the estimated property tax for 5 Onondaga St?
About $33,903 using published city, Rye City school, and town/county mill rates on the assessed value. Not an official bill.
Who is the owner on the roll for 5 Onondaga St?
The 2026 City of Rye roll lists Geoghegan James & Jessica as the owner for parcel 139-19-1-43. Owner names are public record as published on the assessment roll.
Unofficial. Confirm figures on the City of Rye PROS before decisions. School district: Rye City School District.